Ramaphosa Seeks Tech Investment Abroad as Regulator Stifles it at Home
David Christianson
– November 16, 2026
4 min read

This is a paid article which your subscription is allowing you to read.
President Cyril Ramaphosa is visiting Silicon Valley in California this week to learn about high-tech industry and promote the South African market. But even as he does so, the Independent Communications Authority of South Africa (ICASA), the industry regulator in South Africa, is making it unlikely that any interest created will generate investment.
ICASA has obstinately held the position that no broadcasting network or internet business will be licensed unless at least 30% of its shares are held by black or otherwise historically disadvantaged people. The most high-profile case is that of satellite internet operator Starlink, which first signalled its intention to launch in South Africa in February 2021.
South Africa would have been among the first markets in which Starlink was rolled out. But nearly six years later, the issue is in limbo. Starlink’s owner, SpaceX, the aerospace, telecommunications, and artificial intelligence conglomerate founded by South African-born tech entrepreneur Elon Musk, has stated it must retain sole ownership of all its global subsidiaries for operational reasons and was therefore not prepared to sell equity to local partners in any market.
Starlink’s position is far from unique. Most multinational corporations with a presence in South Africa have refused to dilute equity. The list includes other tech companies like Microsoft, Amazon, Samsung, IBM, and Hewlett-Packard. In these cases and others, like auto manufacturers, the companies offer what in South Africa are called equity-equivalent programmes. These involve company initiatives in areas such as education, training, enterprise development, or contributions to dedicated supplier development funds.
ICASA has refused to consider Starlink eligible for an equity-equivalent programme, even after Communications Minister Solly Malatsi directed it to do so late last year. Standing on its independence as a Chapter 9 institution, ICASA argued in a decision released in May that it was obliged, in terms of Section 9(2)(b) of the Electronic Communications Act of 2005, to insist on the 30% black equity clause and could not comply with Malatsi’s directive unless the law was amended.
Starlink’s main impact would be in areas outside the footprint of South Africa’s cellular networks. It would provide communications capacity to cattle and sheep ranches, game farms, rural tourist sites, and offshore coastal areas where it might be used by commercial fishing fleets, cargo ships, and private yachts. The company has said that an element of its equity offset programme would be free high-speed internet connections which it would offer to 5 000 rural schools in perpetuity.
ICASA’s interpretation of its own founding legislation is now being challenged by Sakeliga in the Pretoria High Court. The business organisation points out that wording of the relevant clause clearly allows for equity-equivalent schemes. The Act says that licensing conditions are either “(equity of) not less than 30%, or such other conditions or higher percentage as may be prescribed”.
Sakeliga argues that the phrase “or such other conditions” gives ICASA a choice in the matter, which means the 30% quota is not obligatory. The business organisation is asking the court to set aside ICASA’s May decision and to declare that Section 9(2)(b) does not necessitate a racial quota. If the court for any reason baulks at such decisions, Sakeliga has requested that it at least declare the clause “unconstitutional and invalid because it imposes an irrational and arbitrary quota”.
ICASA’s stand has been widely criticised. Critics include Telkom, the semi-privatised South African telecommunications and information technology company, which, earlier this year, released a statement arguing that the regulator’s interpretation of empowerment rules went beyond what the legislation had envisaged. Telkom asserted that the subsequent uncertainty “has potentially deterred much-needed investment” in the country’s information and communications networks.
Telkom is correct. At issue is not just Starlink but all businesses that require a licence to provide internet access, broadcasting services (including television and radio), or to operate network infrastructure. Empowerment criteria apply to all applications for radio frequency spectrum, company mergers, and other commercial transactions. Mobile operators like MTN, Vodacom, and Telkom are required to top up empowerment equity if needed to maintain the 30% empowerment threshold. New entrants to the industry and potential foreign investors will be inhibited and competition stifled.
Ramaphosa may believe that his five-day jaunt to California could, as the government press release suggests, “strengthen [South Africa’s] artificial intelligence capabilities, attract investment and position [the country] to participate meaningfully in the rapidly evolving global technology landscape”. But unless the investment climate is changed to facilitate, not inhibit, the high-tech sector, it might well have been more productive for him to stay at home.
Subscribe to unlock this article
To support our journalism, and unlock all of our investigative stories and provocative commentary, subscribe below.